A former Arnprior resident has taken the stand at the Pembroke courthouse as he answers to charges of attempted murder, kidnapping, aggravated assault and for issuing death threats. 74-year-old William or “Bill” Kirby started the day off being questioned by his defense lawyer. Kirby told the court what he remembered of the 13th of September, 2018.
The court heard that Kirby used to live nearby and walk his dog in the wooded area at the end of Gunsmith Road where the victim was found with stab wounds.
When asked if he brought the victim out to the secluded area with the intentions of killing her, Kirby replied “most definitely not”. Kirby testified that the victim got in his car willingly for her 30-minute lunch break, and he wanted to go somewhere private to talk about their relationship. Kirby told the court there was too many people at the Park n’ Ride in Arnprior to have a private conversation so they kept driving. While on the stand last week, the victim told the court she did not agree to go anywhere and left her car running, unlocked with the drivers side window down. Kirby admitted to the court today, the victim asked to be let out of the vehicle two or three times before they arrived at Gunsmith Road in McNab/Braeside, approximately 20-minutes from the victims place of work.
Kirby testified that the victim got out of the car and started hitting him with a log or a stick. Kirby told the court he reached into the drivers door and picked up a knife, holding it out in front of him and telling the victim “now we’re even” because he had the knife and she still had the stick. Kirby testified that the victims stomach was cut when he was pushing her away from him. The victim told the court a different story last week saying when they got out of the vehicle, Kirby put his hand on her shoulder and told her “today’s your day to die you lying s**t” and stabbed her in the stomach. Kirby denied those allegations.
Kirby told the court if he wanted to kill the victim he would have used the drywall knife that was in the back of his vehicle with his tools. Kirby also told the court if he wanted to kill the victim “she wouldn’t be here today”. The weapon used to stab the victim is described as a throwing knife and two others from the same set were found in Kirby’s vehicle.
After the first alleged stabbing, Kirby told the court the two walked around in the woods moving to several locations and had a couple of cigarettes. Kirby testified that the victim took off and fell down a large gully where she cut her ear and there was blood everywhere. The victim testified that she never saw Kirby stab her the second time, but he was walking behind her when she felt a sharp pain in the neck, took a couple of steps and crawled into the fetal position. Kirby told the court the two were in the bush for 1.5 to 2-hours before paramedics arrived.
A 40-minute audio recording that was submitted as evidence captures Kirby trying to take his own life, calling 911 for help and the victim begging to not be left alone in the bushes. The audio recording was captured from a personal recording device Kirby had on him at the time of the arrest. The recording appears to have started after the second alleged stabbing, but it remains unclear if it was started intentionally or not.
Kirby disputed most of the evidence presented by the Crown Attorney during cross-examination this afternoon. Kirby appeared visibly frustrated on the stand and one of his responses to the crown was “whatever you say, I’m not getting through to you”. At the end of the day, while still on the stand Kirby told the court, “Here I am in court for the most ridiculous charge I’ve ever heard of”, he went on to say “I’m 74 I’ve lived a good life”.
Kirby remains out on bail before he is sentenced in a sexual assault case he was found guilty in back in November (2020). Kirby was found guilty of two counts of assault, one count of sexual assault, another count of indecent assault and for pointing a firearm. Sentencing will take place in March of 2021.
The crown will continue cross-examination at the Pembroke courthouse tomorrow morning (January 13th, 2021). Closing statements in the trial are expected to be made by the end of the week. If found guilty of the charges he is currently facing, Kirby will likely spend the rest of his life behind bars.
PREVIOUS STORIES:
https://www.pembroketoday.ca/2021/01/07/defense-questions-victim-over-attempted-murder-and-kidnapping-charges/
https://www.pembroketoday.ca/2021/01/06/victim-takes-the-stand-as-kirby-back-on-trial-for-attempted-murder-and-kidnapping/
